1949 Peglegs

1949 Peglegs Milo Misut, Richard Koomey, Bernard Levine, George Booke Arthur Kornhaber, Leon Stand, Edward Weinstein, Julius Richman

1950 Peglegs

1950 Peglegs Herbert Schaarschmidt, Carl Appey, Paul Hoffman, Al Hyman, Paul Cilmi Leon Freilich, Donald Herbstman, Jack Leif, Robert McCormack, Gary Mirsky Frank Perdichezzi, Donald Reed, Angelo Rombde, Michael Sedran, Morton Stillman

1951 Peglegs

1951 Peglegs – Left to Right Back Row – Arthur Slavin, Niel Butwin, Bill Morganstein, Front Row – Si Harkavy, Art Walsh

1952 Peglegs

1952 Peglegs – Left to Right Back Row – Len Ammaturo*, Art Hessel, Vinny Rago*, Tony Bartilucci*, David Levine, Don Timmerman*, Howie Norris, Larry Hefter* 3rd Row – Art Reckler*, Bob Pagano, Bob Briggi, Fred Gilligan*, Bill Fleischer*, Fredrick Fred* 2nd Row – Art Horowitz*, Ron Brooks*, Howard Adler, George Hiller, Jay Adrian, Howie Tepper*, Hank Nadler* Front Row – Coach Moses Davis, Don Jaffe, Richard Bronstein, Karl Muller*, Eric Lederer*, Leroy Sawyer, Mike Vigod, Len Saltman, Alan Curtis

* member 1953 Championship team

1953 Peglegs

1953 Peglegs
Eric Lederer, Art Hessel, Art Reckler, Jack Zulain, Larry Hefter, Pete Salzer, Tony Bartilucci,Art Horowitz, Jay Hoffman

1954 Peglegs

1954 Peglegs

1955 Peglegs

1955 Peglegs Gerry Treger, Marty Stillman, Al Slovin, Peter Nunez, Ed Lieberman, Marv Schiff, Bob Tancredi, Joe Demato, George Gluck, Ed Abrams, Don Polsky, Nobert Baer

1956 Peglegs

1956 Peglegs (4W - 7L) – Left to Right
Front Row –  Donald Ferrara* (4th from left), Mel Wallis* (5th from left)

* Co-captains
Note: Won/Loss record per The Spectator - Volume 85, Issue 5

1957 Peglegs

1957 Peglegs Allan Berkowitz, Kenneth Brater, Harold Clark, Ronald Weiss, Robert Cornell, Andrew DeLuise, Leonard Gootblatt, George Hejduk,David Hersey, Stephen Hurst, David Lieberman, Ray Maccagli, Jeff Luria, Richard Scharp, Roger Panetta, Al Russo, Barry Milowitz, Sanford Ratzan, Harvey Rosen, Charles Rosenthal, Raymond Russell, Bernard Salick, John Schmerler, Stanley Shapiro, Warren Fox

1958 Peglegs

1958 Peglegs Henry Serry, Charles Palant, Richard Bard, Joel Black, Martin Bandiero, Rodeny Brinton, Robert Edelson, Leonard Goodisman, Fren Hansen, Eugene Josephs, Steve Morris, Mike Oliphant, Allan Putterman, Bert Quarfordt, Mike Rosen, Ray Silverstein, Elliott Webb, Robert Wolkowitz, Dennis Margaris, Steve Tobin

1959 Peglegs

1959 Peglegs Alexander Horowitz, Philip Levitt, Paul D'Angela, Joseph Lamonte, Laurence Hymowitz, Arthur Barocas, Harvey Milman, Michael Rosen, Stephen Abramson, Herbert Browning